Is it ever ok to work for free?

Is it ever ok to work for free? You’re probably thinking this will be a really short post as the answer would be a definite “no”!

However, it’s not as straightforward as that. Not every situation is the same. And not every one is straightforward, so having a blanket “no free work policy” might not be the best option.

So today, let’s look at some of these situations.  I’m going to be talking about them as they apply to the design industry since that’s where I have experience, but the same (or similar) principles can apply to your industry too.

Spec Work

This is easy an easy one – the answer definitely is no!

When a client asks a designer to provide some samples before deciding whether or not to hire them, that’s spec (or speculative) work. Creating samples takes time and there’s no guarantee the designer will ever get paid for producing them. So since time is precious, the designer would be smarter to spend that time working on projects they know they’ll get paid for. In this instance, time really is money.

Spec work seems to be something peculiar to the creative industries. Like, you wouldn’t ask 3 restaurants to cook you a meal and only pay for the one you like most. Or ask 3 plumbers to fix your leaky tap and only pay the one you think did the best job.

Spec work devalues the whole design industry, so for years I’ve had a strict no spec policy. Whenever I’ve been asked to provide samples I explain (politely, of course!) to the client that the samples they are asking for are spec work, which is really unnecessary as they can judge the quality and style of my work from my portfolio.

For more info check out the Anti-spec and No-spec websites.

Competitions

Entering competitions is a more complex situation.

Some competitions are thinly veiled calls for spec work. For example, a company running a contest to design their logo and offering the winner a nominal cash prize. The motivation behind such a competition is usually to get as many logo ideas as possible for as small a sum of money as possible.

With other competitions the promoter’s motivation is more about rewarding genuine creativity. The brief might not be for a real end-product (such as the company’s new logo) however the prize may be much more valuable, for example being featured in a magazine which would provide invaluable publicity for the designer.

Obviously, with no guarantee of reward, it’s not always a good idea to spend time entering competitions. But if the prize is something you’d find really valuable and you can spare the time without impacting your other projects, there’s no harm in trying.

Charities

Everyone loves supporting a good cause, right?

It’s tempting to work for free for a charity simply because it is a charity. So if it’s a cause you feel strongly about and you can spare the time, then it should be ok to donate your services if that’s what you want to do.

However, most charities do have a budget set aside for things like marketing, since that’s an essential part of raising awareness of their cause and work. So they should be able to pay you something for your services. Or you could meet in the middle. Instead of working completely for free, you could offer them a discount.

Family

You may feel obliged to work for free for family members and actually that’s ok because they’re your family!

Even so, it’s usually best to have a contract in place as you will have to make it clear that paid work will be a priority over their freebie. Plus, if this is to be an ongoing arrangement, you might be best to suggest a limit to the amount of work provided or try a skill swap instead.

Friends

This is another tricky one. I know of some designers who won’t work with their friends at all as they don’t want to mix business and friendship, or risk things not turning out well and losing a friend. I can understand that as in the past I’ve been taken advantage of by people that I considered friends.

However, I’ve also had several successful projects with friends. The difference was treating them the same as all my other clients. They had the same onboarding process, they paid the same rates, got the same contract, and the standard of work as all my other clients.

It’s up to you whether you offer ‘mates rates’ or not. But if you’re going to work with friends, I’d definitely recommend following your usual business processes and practices. Business and friendship can mix as long as you both treat your working relationship professionally.

Is it ever ok to work for free?

As you can see there are several situations in which you could be asked, or feel obliged to offer your services for free.

Ultimately it’s up to you on whether or not you do it. It’s perfectly ok to decline though – and you shouldn’t feel guilty about doing so, as there are always other options you can consider.

[Tweet “Is it ever ok to work for free? The answer might not always be so straightforward…”]

This post was first published in 2013 and was last updated in 2021.