In web design, what comes first: the design or the copy?

Graphic with text reads "Content or web design - what should come first?" Background is pale mint green with illustrations of a coffee cup, hears and a computer screen.

“What do you mean by content?” It’s a question I hear from my web design clients ALL THE TIME.

Because when you need a new website you know you need it to look great, you know you need great functionality, and you know you need it to convert interested readers into buyers.

But what you don’t always know is that design is only one part of that equation. You also need to think about the copy: the words you’ll be using on your site.

Because here’s the thing:

“Design in the absence of content isn’t design, it’s decoration”
— Jeffrey Zeldman

Great content isn’t just an afterthought — it’s a necessity.

But how do you know where it fits into the website design process? And if it’s so essential, should you get a copywriter/content writer on board before you even look at potential designers?

How the Dickens does it all work?

Well, because it’s one of my FAQs, I figured you could use a little video to help clear things up — and because it doesn’t make sense to talk copy without the input of my favourite copy and content writer, I’ve roped Clare Crossan into talking it over with me.

Hit play to find out:

  • Whether design or copy should come first (and why getting it wrong can be a costly mistake).
  • Whether you should hire a designer or a copywriter first.
  • The one thing you can do to make the whole process easier.

Visit Clare’s website

Follow Clare on Instagram

Follow Fiona on Instagram

Subscribe for more videos

Hire us to create your website


Transcript

A copywriter and designer go head-to-head

[0:04] Clare:
Hi everyone. I don’t know if you caught our video a few months ago. It was our first ever foray into video, and we were both absolutely bricking it, but we did it, and we had an awful lot of fun, actually, didn’t we?

[0:18] Fiona:
We really did. Surprisingly fun!

[0:21] Clare:
Surprisingly fun, yeah. So we’ve decided to have some more fun and maybe make this a bit of a regular gig, if you’re very lucky.

So today’s video, we’re going to tackle a topic that we have both heard many, many times over the years from various clients. It’s a question that a lot of people do wonder when they come to do a web project, what comes first? Is it the design, or is it the copy?

And actually it’s a bit of a raw nerve, or can be a raw nerve for creative types, because, and especially if you go in house, I think, is there’s this classic, cliched rivalry between designers and copywriters, and it’s that whole question of, what is the king of the castle? Is it is design more important to your website, or is the content more important?

So in this video, we’re getting the gloves on, and we’re going to fight it out. We are going to decide what is more important, the design or the content and more relevant to you guys, is, who should you hire first? Should you look for a copywriter first, or should you look for a designer?

So we do it?

[1:39] Fiona:
Let’s!

The importance of content and design working together

[1:40] Clare:
Okay. So here’s where it gets slightly less dramatic after we’ve just put our gloves on, I think we should take them off again, because as far as I’m concerned, design and copy are absolutely equally important. Wouldn’t you say?

[1:56] Fiona:
Definitely. I mean design without the copy. It’s like the macaroni without the cheese. It’s no fun at all.

So yeah, at the risk of getting on my soapbox, like you need to have content to design around, if you’ve got so there’s this quote that I’m probably misquoting, but it’s, “Design without content is just decoration”.

So if you’ve got a lovely design, I mean, yay. You want your site to be pretty, but it needs to work. It needs to convert people from just looking to actually buying, whether that’s filling in a contact form, make an appointment, you know, or buying actually there on your site, you need to have the content and the design working together to guide them to that point.

[2:58] Clare:
Yeah, I absolutely agree. It’s another marketing sort of cliche thing, but there very much is a buyer’s journey, isn’t there?

There’s, there’s taking someone from that… it starts with your headline, doesn’t it? Grabbing someone with your headline and just saying to them, “Hi, yes, you’re, you’re, yep, this is the right spot. You have found the right page. Yeah, read on, please.”

And then the copy will take them on a journey from letting them know they’re in the right place, to making them understand that you really get what their problems are, to then offering them the solutions, to convincing them that you are the person that actually can help them, to getting them to the point where they actually are ready to click the buy button or the schedule a consultation button, or whatever your call to action is. The copy really, really drives that journey.

However, it doesn’t matter how super sexy your copy is. If the design falls flat, it’s not going to work. If the user experience is terrible, it’s not going to work. If they’re frustrated because there are a million buttons and they don’t know which one to press, it’s not going to work. Iif the copy and the design don’t mesh, if they just seem like they aren’t part of the same website,

[4:24] Fiona:
Yeah, the tones and it just wouldn’t have the same effect.

[4:28] Clare:
Yeah, exactly. So great copy is important, but the design, without the design, your copy is just going to fall flat.

[4:38] Fiona:
Absolutely, because design is about communicating, and in order to do that, you know, for a website, you need to communicate the information quickly and easily in order to get people to convert.

And if you don’t have any content, the design has nothing to communicate, and it’s… You know, it might be pretty, but it’s still going to fail. You know, you’re not going to reach your conversion goals. You know, it’s, it’s just going to be really, that looks nice in my portfolio.

[5:13] Clare:
It’s back to that quote, isn’t it? It’s just decoration, yeah.

Challenges of separate design and copy processes

[5:26] Clare:
Okay, so very cool. Important. So it’s one all so far. Okay, no clear winner yet. But this is where I might win a little point, because I think there is a hierarchy as such when it comes to starting your project. And I think copy might just win this one.

[5:38] Fiona:
Well, this is rather controversial coming from a designer, but hell yeah!

I’ve, you know, I, for a very long time, I have advocated the Content First approach, which you know, as you might imagine from the name, starts with the content.

Because when I’m given content to design around, I can look at it and go right. I know exactly how this page is going to end up looking. I know what needs to be highlighted. I know what’s important. I know how this site is going to flow, how someone should hopefully navigate through it.

Whereas, if I’m designing round dummy text, you know the “lorem ipsum” stuff that you see quite a lot… I’m basically just doing what I think is a cool design, and then the client has to kind of shoehorn some content into predetermined spaces, like, “Oh, I’ve got three lines of text to fill in here… I’ve got two paragraphs of text needed there…”

It’s, you know, it might work, but there’s a good chance that something is going to go wrong.

[6:48] Clare:
Yeah. And if you’re at the point where you’re shoehorning, then it’s likely your strategy, if you ever had one, has flown out the window by that point.

[6:58] Fiona:
Yeah. Most likely you never had one in the first place. That’s what I found.

And then, you know, you either have to, I think you’d agree, you’d have to pay your copywriter extra to fit, you know, to make the content fit into this design, or you have to pay your designer extra to make the design change to fit this content that you now have.

[7:24] Clare:
I’ve definitely had that before.

I’ve had where I’ve written the copy, and then the designer has come into the project and not really taking the copy into account. So the client will come back and say, “Okay, well, I really like that, but the designer says it needs to fit into this box. So can we just shave 300 words off it?”

Now, when I’m writing copy, and I’m sure all copywriters would say the same thing, there are no superfluous words that are just there to look pretty. You know, every word, every comma, every exclamation mark has been chosen with a purpose. It’s there for a reason.

So shaving any words off it and trying to make a paragraph fit into a smaller box isn’t an easy job. It’s not, generally speaking, it’s not a small edit. It’s a rewrite. So it’s going to take a lot of time. It’s going to mess with the deadlines, and it is going to cost more money as well.

And it’s a shame, because it’s not something that has to happen.

[8:32] Fiona:
Oh, it’s completely avoidable.

[8:34] Clare:
It’s completely avoidable. So that begs the question, then, should you always contact the copywriter first, or it? Should you contact the designer first?

Advantages of taking a collaborative approach to your website

[8:48] Fiona:
Well, this is where I might score the points, because I’m obviously very lucky in that I have you I have a good relationship with my very own copywriter.

So, you know, someone coming. I mean, people tend not to think about copywriting. They they come to me, they want, they know, they want a new website. And then I, you know, go through my list of questions, and I’m like, so do you have the content? Are you working on it? Or do you need some help with that?

And it invariably falls into two categories.

Hardly anyone says, “Yes, I have the content already to rock.”

It’s either “What do you mean content?”, and I’m like “the words that go on your page”, obviously more politely than that, but that’s the gist of it.

Or they’re like, “Well, I can give it a bash, but you know, I might need a bit of help.” And you know, with those two things, I’m lucky that I can say, “In that case, I know just the woman who can help you out”.

Because having worked together so many times, you know what an effective website needs, you know how to prepare the content so that it’s dead easy for me to put it into the website as I’m building it. You know, it totally streamlines the process. And I know that by referring my clients to you, you know, not only is it going to make my life easier, but I know that they are going to get, you know, the professional service and quality work that my design needs! They’re going to get the good stuff that they need in order to meet their goals.

[10:55] Clare:
Yeah, I think, from my point of view as well, it means that the work I do is much more effective as well, because I know that… Well, first of all, while we say that content comes first, often, you’ll have gone over strategy with the clients.

[11:13] Fiona:
I do do a lot of strategy, yeah.

[11:16] Clare:
So we know which products, for example, or which services we want to highlight on the homepage. We kind of have an idea of the buyer’s journey to use that one again. We kind of know where we want them to go. We know what the website has to achieve, which is a really, really great jumping off point for the copy.

So it gives me somewhere to start with, something to start with, and I know as well, when I’m writing it, that I can just do my thing and that it’s not going to come back to me in three weeks saying, can you just shave 300 words off this? You know, I know that whatever I come up with, assuming it fits with the overall strategy wey’ve agreed, I know that you can make it work.
I mean, which gives me a lot of freedom in my writing.

[12:07] Fiona:
Yeah, usually when I get the content from you, I just open up the file and, you know, I can… things start falling into place. I can see all right, here’s a section there, I’m going to need to find an image for that. Here’s something that needs to be highlighted. I kind of start designing it in my head as soon as I look at the content, which, yeah, it’s a lot harder when it’s either written by the client or by another copywriter.

[12:35] Clare:
Yeah, I think that probably is because we worked together for so many years. Because I often find when I’m writing, I sort of have an idea of, I think I could see how this could work design wise. I’m not a designer. I can’t do what you do, yeah. But I think because we have done so many projects together, that I can kind of think…

[12:53] Fiona:
You know how I do what I do.

[12:54] Clare:
Exactly, which I think brings us really to our main point is, let’s just take the gloves off altogether.

[13:05] Fiona:
Yeah, because it’s not about you winning or me winning. It’s about us winning by working together, right?

[13:13] Clare:
Well, it’s about the client winning. Let’s get cheesy about it now! Because you know that ultimately, is what happens is that when we actually work together, it’s easier in a logistical way, I find, because we can, instead of the client having to try and liaise with completely two separate parties and trying to work with all the different deadlines and the moving parts involved, we can just say, okay, when can you do the copy? When do you need the copy? Yeah, and come up with a schedule that works for both.

[13:47] Fiona:
Absolutely because, you know, I, if I’m… on the projects where I’m not working with you, you know, I have, I basically just have to say to the client, this is when I need your content. And then I have to trust that they are going to tell their copywriter, or, you know, do it themselves, that they that is when they’re going to deliver.

And so many times things have been late because, oh, but we only just booked the photographer, so it’s going to be another three weeks or, Oh, we only just, you know, the the edits aren’t quite finished on our content, so we need extra time, and that just throws my entire schedule off.

It delays the launch of that client’s website. And then I have to go to the next project and try and like, oh, can I can I scrunch things up? Can I move things around? You know, I have try and do that without screwing over the next client.

[14:44] Clare:
Which obviously just can’t happen because, yeah, it’s not their fault.

[14:48] Fiona:
And I have to do it without screwing over my own life as well.

[14:52] Clare:
Yeah, well, yeah, work life balance, people, it’s important.

Well, I’ve heard it’s a thing.

And, yeah, but that really is the crux of it, isn’t it? When, when your designer and your copywriter are working together, there are the logistical things that are so much easier, like the deadline, so much easier. There’s the fact that you have two creative heads to put together, to talk about concepts, to talk about strategy, and all of the kind of bigger picture stuff that is actually really, really important, because neither design or copy works unless you have the overall strategy sort of nailed in the first place.

[15:34] Fiona:
And it’s just it’s so much easier when you you form that team.

[15:41] Clare:
Oh, just very much as they I think the smoothest projects that I ever work on are the ones that we work on together, and it is precisely for that reason, because the process is just… because we can collaborate from the very, very beginning of a project to make sure that we’re both on the same page, and it’s the right page for the client, most importantly.

So we’ve answered the question.

[16:09] Fiona:
We have, yeah.

[16:14] Clare:
You don’t have to think about copy first or design first. It’s a team. It’s, it’s…

[16:19] Fiona:
It’s the Dream Team!

[16:27] Clare:
Oh my goodness! So cheesy!

So if all that rambling has you convinced that we actually are the dream team to work on your website, and we really are, by the way, give Fi a shout. She will talk you through which branding package will be the best fit for you, and be sure to let her know that you need content as well. And then she can give me a shout and bring me on board.

So if you want to get in touch with Fiona, you will find all the details down there that you need to contact her.